There's nothing fishy about the menu at this Dominican eatery—well, except for all the fish. Punta Cana's inventive entrees include red snapper, kingfish or cod made with exquisitely seasoned sauces. If you prefer turf to surf, the menu features many tempting takes on steak, but go for the rabo encendido (oxtail) or chivo guisado (goat stew) if you're feeling adventurous. The main dishes are all superb and affordable at $11-15 per plate, but the true power punch comes at the top of the menu. Dominican fare is well known for championing the mighty plantain, and Punta Cana stays true to its roots by serving them up crispy with garlic sauce, sweetened with sugar and a side of sour cream, or flattened and fried as tostones. If you aren't quite feeling the plantains, try the yuca al mojo de ajo (fried yuca root in garlic sauce) for a definitive Cuban treat. Serious diners would do well to order some empanadas, traditional stuffed pastries filled with ground beef, chicken or cheese that will make a quick addict out of anyone.

The drink menu is loaded with fresh coconut, tamarind and passion fruit juices, but we adore the lemonade, made fresh and sold by the pitcher. The pina colada is made simply with coconut and pineapple juices, sans alcohol. For a more authentic swill, the morir-sonando, a Dominican classic which translates as "to die dreaming," lives up to its name with fresh oranges, crushed ice, sugar and cream.

Lunch specials at Punta Cana are particularly good deals. For less than eight bucks, choose from pollo, beef or pork dishes that come with sides of rice, beans and salad. Or choose from the amazing sandwich menu—the Cuban features roasted pork, ham, pickles and cheese. The equally delicious Jibarito has sautéed steak, garlic sauce and cheese squeezed between fried plantains.

Average cost: $10-$20

Centerstage Reviewer: K. Tighe